AKA: Father Eli
Actor: Drew Carey

Concept

Open-Minded Priest

Tropes

The "cool" priest
Can potentially "kick arse for the Lord"
Medical training
Willing to shelter a vigilante or two
Knows a thing or two about supernatural creatures—possibly has "seen things"
Coffee drinker
Knows his Bible, and church history
Worked at the church D'Angelos attended back in the day; started there a bit before Rafe's eyes mutated, so he remembers when that happened, and how it affected him
Currently works at the church on the same block as Rafe's apartment
Did some missionary work in Africa back in the day