AKA: Father Eli
Actor: Drew Carey

Concept

Open-Minded Priest

Tropes

The "cool" priest
Can potentially "kick arse for the Lord"
Medical training
Willing to shelter a vigilante or two
Knows a thing or two about supernatural creatures—possibly has "seen things"
Coffee drinker
Knows his Bible, and church history
Worked at the church D'Angelos attended back in the day; started there a bit before Rafe's eyes mutated, so he remembers when that happened, and how it affected him